Media Reality as a Tool of Public Opinion Influence (on the Example of Temporarily Occupied Territories in the Zaporizhia Region)

K. But

Abstract


The purpose of the study is to examine media reality as a tool of propaganda and manipulation in the context of influencing public opinion, demonstrate the means of its construction using regional print media and digital media as examples, operating in the temporarily occupied territories of the Zaporizhia region.

Research methodology. During the research, methods of systematization, analysis, and synthesis were applied. The author conducted a review and fact-checking of printed and digital materials from the temporarily occupied territories of the Zaporizhia region to examine the media reality portrayed in them. The sample included propagandistic materials from June that were disseminated in the temporarily occupied territories of the Zaporizhia region, including excerpts from the newspaper «Parliamentary Assembly of the Union of Belarus and Russia» (June 23–29, 2023, No. 26), «Zaporozhsky Vestnik» (No. 10), and digital materials (specifically, the Telegram channel «Zaporozhsky Vestnik» and the website ZP-news.ru). Hypotheses were also formulated regarding how media reality can influence public opinion.

Results. In this study, we examined potential tools of media reality influence on public opinion (using the example of citizens residing in temporarily occupied territories of the Zaporizhia region). The theoretical analysis indicated that the impact of media reality on the consciousness of individuals and groups was explored as far back as the previous century. However, the topic remains relevant to this day. Among the key works that laid the foundation for this research, it is worth mentioning the contributions of H. Adorno, P. Bourdieu, J. Baudrillard, R. Barthes, G. Lasswell, M. McLuhan, I. Matsishina, O. Moskvich, M. Sanakoyev, L. Chernyavska, and others. Notably, communication scholars V. Schramm and D. Roberts pointed out that governmental structures seek to present a different reality to society when they sense a lack of their own strength and convictions. The proposed author’s definition of the concept of media reality is as follows: a constructed socio-cultural reality, a virtual space, a collection of phenomena and processes reflected or distorted in the media that influence perception, understanding, and the way people interact with the real world, shape public opinion, and can be directed towards changing consumer behavior. Additionally, a practical analysis of propagandistic sources introduced in circulation in the temporarily occupied territories of the Zaporizhia region suggests that constructing media reality is a crucial element of mass influence. This is achieved through a range of instruments, including the creation of an information vacuum, the application of «pseudo-fact-checking» or accusing the Ukrainian side of disseminating false information, omission or downplaying of information, crafting specific symbols and visual images to impact the subconscious, publishing emotional content, activating the «spiral of silence», and frequent repetition of messages.

Practical significance. In the context of Russia’s information warfare against Ukraine, the research findings can be applied to develop countermeasures against hostile propaganda and reintegrating residents in the temporarily occupied territories.

Key words: propaganda, media reality, fakes, narratives, information war, media literacy, key messages, temporarily occupied territories of Zaporizhzhia region, manipulation, fact-checking.


References


Brudnytska, L. (2004). Symvolistychnist reklamnoi realnosti yak zmodelovanoho snovydinnia [Symbolism of advertising reality as a simulated dream]. Kultura narodiv Prychornomoria, 2, 49, 37–38 [in Ukrainian].

But, K. Natsyzm, ukrainski dyversanty ta manipuliatsii: chervneva propahanda na tymchasovo okupovanykh terytoriiakh Zaporizkoi oblasti [Nazism, Ukrainian saboteurs, and manipulations: June propaganda in the temporarily occupied territories of the Zaporizhia region]. Mediahramotnist u rehionakh Ukrainy. Retrieved from https://milukraine.net/2023/06/chervneva-propaganda-na-tot/ [in Ukrainian].

But, K. (Ne) maiu prava: prava liudyny na tymchasovo okupovanykh terytoriiakh Zaporizkoi oblasti [(Un)have the right: human rights in the temporarily occupied territories of the Zaporizhia region]. Mediahramotnist u rehionakh Ukrainy. Retrieved from https://milukraine.net/2022/11/prava-liudini-na-timchasovo-okupovanikh-teritotiyax/ [in Ukrainian].

But, K. (2022). Propahanda ta mediarealnist yak instrumenty vedennia informatsiinoi viiny: lokalnyi vymir [Propaganda and media reality as tools of information warfare: a local dimension]. Derzhava ta rehiony. Seriia: Sotsialni komunikatsii, 4 (52), 24–33 [in Ukrainian].

Hazeta «Hazeta parlamentskoho sobranyia soiuza Belarusy y Rossyy». (2023), 26 [in Russian].

Hazeta «Zaporozhskyi vestnyk». (2023), 10 [in Russian].

Hladkov, V. (2023). 10 voprosov Hubernatoru [10 questions for the Governor]. Retrieved from https://vk.com/video639631882_ 456241184 [in Ukrainian].

Zaporizka oblast posidaie druhe mistse v Ukraini za kilkistiu proiektiv «Velykoho budivnytstva» na nastupnyi rik [Zaporizhzhia region ranks second in Ukraine in terms of the number of «Major construction» projects for the next year]. Zaporizka oblasna derzhavna administratsiia. Retrieved from https://www.zoda.gov.ua/news/58161/zaporizka-oblast-posidaje-druge-mistse-v-ukrajini-za-kilkistju-projektiv-velikogo-budivnitstva-na-nastupniy-rik.html [in Ukrainian].

«Zaporozhskyi vestnyk»: telehram-kanal [Telegram channel «Zaporozhsky Vestnik»]. Retrieved from https://t.me/zpvestnik [in Russian].

Derzhspetszviazku: telehram-kanal [Telegram channel «State Special Communications»]. Retrieved from https://t.me/dsszzi_official/4797 [in Ukrainian].

Zhurnalistka hromadske Viktoriia Roshchyna ymovirno perebuvaie v poloni v rosiiskykh okupantiv [Journalist Victoria Roshchina is likely in captivity of Russian occupiers]. Hromadske. Retrieved from https://hromadske.ua/posts/zhurnalistka-hromadske-viktoriya-roshina-jmovirno-perebuvaye-v-poloni-v-rosijskih-okupantiv [in Ukrainian].

Kasiian, V. U Kyievi okupanty potsilyly v televezhu, chastyna telekanaliv ne pratsiuie (video) [In Kyiv, occupiers targeted the TV tower, some TV channels are not working (video)]. LB.ua. Retrieved from https://lb.ua/society/2022/03/01/507558_kiievi_okupanti_potsilili_televezhu.html [in Ukrainian].

Koval, A. (2022). Typovi henderni obrazy litnikh liudei v ukrainskykh serialakh [Typical gender images of elderly people in Ukrainian TV series]. Ukrainskyi Informatsiinyi Prostir, 9, 88–98 [in Ukrainian].

Kumok, T. Sehodnia utrom okkupanty vykraly papu… Kumoka Mykhayla Vladymyrovocha [Today in the morning, the occupiers kidnapped Dad... Kumok Mikhail Vladimirovich]. Retrieved from https://www.facebook.com/PinkPantherWedding/posts/5156784241040256 [in Russian].

Lutsenko, Ye. Na Luhanshchyni okupanty pereviriaiut mobilni telefony mistsevykh cherez aktyvnist Syl oborony – Henshtab [In Luhansk, occupiers check mobile phones of locals due to the activity of the Defense Forces – General Staff]. Hromadske. Retrieved from https://hromadske.ua/posts/na-luganshini-okupanti-pereviryayut-mobilni-telefoni-miscevih-cherez-aktivnist-sil-oboroni-genshtab [in Ukrainian].

Mykhayl Vedernykov: telehram-kanal [Telegram channel «Mikhail Vedernikov»]. Retrieved from https://t.me/MV_007_Pskov/2962 [in Russian].

Na Zaporizhzhi okupanty namahalysia rozstriliaty v odnomu iz sil vyshku z ukrainskym mobilnym zviazkom [In Zaporizhzhia, occupiers attempted to destroy a tower with Ukrainian mobile communication]. Retrieved from https://mig.com.ua/na-zaporizhzhi-okupanty-namahalysia-rozstriliaty-v-odnomu-iz-sil-vyshku-z-ukrainskym-mobilnym-zv-iazkom/ [in Ukrainian].

Beili, R. (2023). Otsinka rosiiskoi nastupalnoi kampanii [Assessment of the Russian offensive campaign]. Institute for the Study of War. Retrieved from https://www.understandingwar.org/backgrounder/russian-offensive-campaign-assessment-june-10-2023 [in Ukrainian].

Pidopryhora, I. (2018). Efekt informatsiinoho vakuumu yak chynnyk vplyvu na orhanizatsiiu informatsiino-propahandystskoho zabezpechennia Viiskovo-Morskykh Syl Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy u liutomu – berezni 2014 roku [The effect of the information vacuum as a factor of influence on the organisation of information and propaganda support of the Naval Forces of the Armed Forces of Ukraine in February-March 2014]. Viiskovo-istorychnyi merydian, 5 (19), 64–77 [in Ukrainian].

Rosiiski okupanty zakhopyly redaktsiiu «PRO100» u Berdiansku [Russian occupiers seized the editorial office of «PRO100» in Berdiansk]. Detector media. Retrieved from https://detector.media/community/article/197299/2022-03-08-rosiyski-okupanty-zakhopyly-redaktsiyu-pro100-u-berdyansku/ [in Ukrainian].

Rosiiany pered vidstupom pidirvaly kotelni, vyshky zviazku y teletsentr u Khersoni [Russians blew up boiler rooms, communication towers, and a TV center in Kherson before retreating]. Ukrainska pravda. Retrieved from https://www.pravda.com.ua/news/2022/11/10/7375822/ [in Ukrainian].

Sait ZP-news.ru [ZP-news.ru Website]. Retrieved from http://ZP-news.ru [in Russian].

Spaliek, M. Yak na zvilnenykh terytoriiakh vidnovliuiut mobilnyi zviazok [How mobile communication is being restored in liberated territories]. Detector Media. Retrieved from https://detector.media/infospace/article/203783/2022-10-17-yak-na-zvilnenykh-terytoriyakh-vidnovlyuyut-mobilnyy-zvyazok/ [in Ukrainian].

Televezha v Komyshuvasi: chomu okupanty boiatsia pravdy ta nyshchat teleradiokomunikatsii? [TV tower in Komyshevash: why the occupiers are afraid of the truth and destroy telecommunications?]. IA «Vchasno». Retrieved from https://vchasnoua.com/news/televeza-v-komisuvasi-comu-okupanti-boiatsia-pravdi-ta-nishhat-teleradiokomunikaciyi [in Ukrainian].

Tyshchenko, K. U Melitopoli rosiiany vykraly batka zhurnalistky y vymahaiut yii pryizdu [In Melitopol, Russians kidnapped the father of a journalist and demand her arrival]. Ukrainska pravda. Retrieved from https://www.pravda.com.ua/news/2022/03/23/7333916/ [in Ukrainian].

U Lutsku pidirvaly televezhu – DSNS [In Lutsk, the TV tower was blown up – State Emergency Service]. Hromadske Radio. Retrieved from https://hromadske.radio/news/2022/02/24/u-luts-ku-pidirvaly-televezhu-dsns [in Ukrainian].

U Kharkovi okupanty vluchyly v televezhu, a nasha PPO znyshchyla vorozhyi vynyshchuvach [In Kharkiv, occupiers hit the TV tower, and our air defense destroyed an enemy fighter jet]. Espreso TV. YouTube. 2022. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mk39eZ-69nU [in Ukrainian].

U Prymorsku okupanty vykraly zhurnalista ta aktyvista Kostiantyna Ovsiannykova [In Primorsk, occupiers kidnapped journalist and activist Kostyantyn Ovsyannykov]. Detector Media. Retrieved from https://detector.media/infospace/article/197874/2022-03-26-u-prymorsku-okupanty-vykraly-zhurnalista-ta-aktyvista-kostyantyna-ovsyannykova/ [in Ukrainian].

Cherniavska, L. (2022). Transformatsiia mediarealnosti v umovakh viiny v Ukraini [Transformation of media reality in the conditions of war in Ukraine]. Derzhava ta rehiony. Seriia: Sotsialni komunikatsii, 2, 78–85. Retrieved from http://www.zhu.edu.ua/ journal_cpu/index.php/der_sc/article/view/903/880 [in Ukrainian].

Satariano, A. & Reinhard, S. How Russia Took Over Ukraine’s Internet in Occupied Territories. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://cutt.ly/JwzsRgjd [in English].

Schramm, W., & Roberts, D. F. (1971). The process and effects of mass communication. Chicago: University of Illinois Press [in English].




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.32840/cpu2219-8741/2023.3(55).3

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Since 2013, all electronic versions of the journal are stored in the National Library of Ukraine named after VI Vernadsky of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine and presented on the portal in the information resource "Scientific Periodicals of Ukraine".

Indexing of the journal in scientometric databases:

The publication is indexed by Citefactor: 2019/2020: 4,54.

The journal is indexed by Google Scholar.

In 2020, the journal was included in the Index Copernicus.

The journal is indexed by Innospace Scientific Journal Impact Factor (SJIF): 2016: 5,899, 2017: 6,435, 2018: 7,037, 2019: 7,431

From 2020, the collection is indexed by ResearchBib.

Journal included in the PKP Index.